S. D. V. Stephens

notes / Studies in Algebra and Group Theory / chapter 1: Sets and Groups / From my book

B3.5 Exact Sequences

The isomorphism theorems reveal a pattern: kernels and images of homomorphisms are intimately related. Exact sequences are a compact language for these relationships, and they are the starting point of homological algebra, a subject that runs through modern mathematics from algebraic topology to representation theory to algebraic geometry. We introduce the basic notions here.

3.5.1 Exact Sequences and Their Meaning

Definition 3.5.1 (Exact sequence). A sequence of groups and homomorphisms is exact at if . The sequence is exact if it is exact at every group other than the two ends (if there are ends).

The condition says: an element of is sent to the identity by exactly when it comes from . This is stronger than , which says only that is the trivial homomorphism.

Example 3.5.2 (Exactness encodes injectivity and surjectivity). Write for the trivial group; the only homomorphisms into or out of it are the trivial ones.

  1. is exact at if and only if , that is, is injective.
  2. is exact at if and only if , that is, is surjective.
  3. is exact if and only if is an isomorphism.

3.5.2 Short Exact Sequences

The most important exact sequences are the short ones, which capture quotient groups.

Definition 3.5.3 (Short exact sequence). A short exact sequence is an exact sequence of the form Exactness means: is injective, is surjective, and .

The trivial group is usually written for groups in multiplicative notation and for abelian groups in additive notation, so a short exact sequence appears as or .

Proposition 3.5.4 (Short exact sequences and quotients). If is exact, then is a normal subgroup of isomorphic to , and induces an isomorphism , . Conversely, if , then is exact. So a short exact sequence exists if and only if has a normal subgroup isomorphic to with quotient isomorphic to .

Proof. Suppose the sequence is exact. Since is injective, it is an isomorphism from onto . Exactness at gives , which is normal, and since is surjective the First Isomorphism Theorem gives via .

Conversely, for the inclusion is injective, the projection is surjective, and the image of the inclusion, , is the kernel of the projection (Theorem 3.1.10). For the last statement, given and isomorphisms and , the sequence is exact. ∎

When is exact, we say that is an extension of by .

Example 3.5.5 (Fundamental examples of short exact sequences).

  1. Integers mod : , where is the inclusion and is reduction mod .
  2. Cyclic groups: for positive integers , the sequence , where the first map is and the second is reduction mod . The first map is well defined and injective because if and only if ; its image is the set of multiples of in , which is the kernel of reduction mod . For example, and .
  3. Sign: for . For , with and , this reads . Together with , this shows that the two ends of a short exact sequence do not determine the middle group.
  4. Determinant: (Example 3.3.4).
  5. Center: for any group , , where the second map is (Example 3.3.4).
  6. Products: for any groups and , , where and . This is the “trivial” extension.

Example 3.5.6 (A sequence that does not exist). There is no short exact sequence : it would make the image of a normal subgroup of of order 2, and has none (Example 3.1.12).

3.5.3 Splitting

When does a short exact sequence “come from” a simpler construction? This leads to the notion of splitting.

Definition 3.5.7 (Split exact sequence). A short exact sequence splits if there is a homomorphism with . Such a is called a section (or splitting).

Proposition 3.5.8 (Splitting lemma). If has a section , then every element can be written uniquely as with and .

Proof. Existence: Given , let . Then , so . Write ; then .

Uniqueness: Suppose . Applying gives , since is trivial and . Cancelling gives , and because is injective. ∎

Corollary 3.5.9 (Split sequences of abelian groups). If is a split short exact sequence of abelian groups with section , then , , is an isomorphism. In particular .

Proof. The map is a homomorphism because is abelian: . It is bijective by the splitting lemma. ∎

For non-abelian groups the conclusion fails, because the product need not be multiplicative in the pair . The correct generalization is the semidirect product, studied in Chapter 11: the extensions of by that split are exactly the semidirect products of and . A direct product needs more than a section, namely a retraction onto .

Proposition 3.5.10 (Retractions and direct products). For a short exact sequence , the following are equivalent:

  1. there is a homomorphism with (a retraction);
  2. there is an isomorphism with for all and , where .

Proof. (b) (a): Let , where . Then .

(a) (b): Let , a homomorphism with the two stated properties. It is injective: if and , then for some by exactness, and , so . It is surjective: given , choose with , and set . Then and . ∎

Example 3.5.11 (Split and non-split sequences).

  1. Splits, but is not a product: . The homomorphism with is a section, since and . There is no retraction: by Proposition 3.5.10 it would give , which is abelian, while is not.
  2. Does not split: , with the second map reduction mod 2. A section would satisfy , so , and also , so . This is impossible. (Alternatively: if it split, Corollary 3.5.9 would give , but has an element of order 4 and does not.)

3.5.4 The Extension Problem

Short exact sequences lead to a fundamental question: given groups and , classify all extensions of by , that is, all groups fitting into a short exact sequence . This is a deep problem. The split extensions are the semidirect products of Chapter 11; when is abelian, all extensions, split or not, are classified by cohomology groups , which we will not pursue; and since every finite group is built from simple groups by repeated extensions, the problem lies at the heart of the structure theory of finite groups.

Example 3.5.12 (Extensions of by ). Which groups fit into ? Such a has order 4. There are exactly two groups of order 4 up to isomorphism. Indeed, by Lagrange’s theorem the elements of have order 1, 2, or 4. If some element has order 4, then is cyclic, . Otherwise for all , so is abelian (), and for distinct non-identity elements we get . Both groups occur:

  • , via , which does not split;
  • , via the product sequence, which splits.

So up to isomorphism of the middle group there are exactly two extensions of by .

Question 3.5.13.

  1. Let . Verify that is exact, where the second map is reduction mod .
  2. Let . Show that is exact for a suitable surjection , where is the rotation subgroup. Does it split? Is the direct product ?
  3. Let be a group with normal subgroup . Prove that the sequence is exact (with the obvious maps).
  4. Suppose and are exact. Prove that is exact.
Show solution

(a) Let and let be reduction mod .

Exactness at the first : , since .

Exactness at the second : .

Exactness at : is surjective.

(b) Recall (Proposition 2.2.15) that has order , with rotation subgroup of order and a reflection with . The subgroup has index 2, so it is normal (Proposition 3.1.11), and is a group of order 2, hence isomorphic to . Composing the projection with this isomorphism gives a surjection with kernel , so is exact (Proposition 3.5.4).

Does it split? Yes. Define by and ; it is a homomorphism because . Since , , so . Nevertheless , since is non-abelian ( for ); by Proposition 3.5.10 there is no retraction. In the language of Chapter 11, is a semidirect product of and .

(c) Let be the inclusion and the quotient map.

Exactness at : is injective.

Exactness at : by Theorem 3.1.10.

Exactness at : is surjective.

(d) We check exactness at each position.

At : is injective, by exactness of the first sequence.

At : We need . By exactness of the first sequence, . If , then , so . Conversely, if , then , since is injective; so .

At : We need . Since is surjective, , which equals by exactness of the second sequence.

At : is surjective, by exactness of the second sequence.

Note. Exact sequences are the beginning of homological algebra. The ideas extend to longer exact sequences, and to chain complexes: sequences in which consecutive composites are trivial but which need not be exact, where the failure of exactness is itself the object of study. In representation theory, exact sequences of representations encode how representations are assembled from smaller ones; in topology, long exact sequences are among the most powerful computational tools.